Nichiren writes,
"However, they do not look like those referred to in the sutra: “monks who wear robes and stay in tranquility.” People do not suppose that they are “revered by the people as though they were arhats with Six Super human Powers.” Or, should I say that they are those who are “more cunning and less likely to reveal their faults?”
It is very important to determine who are the cunning monks. Think carefully. Who could be more cunning than a monk who states, "I am not a monk, I am a layman." From the perspective of this age and time, we would have to conclude that it is the business suited lay vice presidents and President of the SGI who are these cunning monks. Those who are looked up to as living Buddhas or having Superhuman Powers ("He could read my thoughts.", "How could anyone but a living Buddha collect so many awards and honors?", "Who but Daisaku Ikeda could write three hundred books." -- discounting of course his dozens of ghost writers) - that is who is the most cunning of the cunning monks.
Nichiren goes on to reveal another way to determine who is in fact the third of the Three Powerful enemies. Here he uses the Zen monks as an example:
"Monks who study only the writings refer to those who are concerned only with the scholastic aspects without understanding the true meaning of the scriptures through wisdom; and Zen monks who are concerned only with formality refer to those who are concerned with the conventions of meditation without firmly grasping the fundamentals. This is the same as the meditation of Brahmans, who will never gain complete freedom from delusions and evil passions. T'ien-t'ai's statement that some Zen monks concentrate only on meditation is an understatement sypathetic to them. In actuality, they lack both practice in meditation as well as wisdom to understand the doctrine. Those who practice Zen consider only the meditation important and pay little attention to the study of doctrines. They interpretate sutras from the viewpoint of meditation in such an absurd way as to say that the eight-fold Evil Path and the Eight Winds make the sixteen-feet tall Buddha, and the Five Elements of all existences and the Three Poisons of greed, anger, and stupidity make the Eight-fold Evil Path. They confuse the six sensory organs with the Six superhuman Powers, or confuste the basic elements of the material world (earth, water, fire, and wind) with the Four Noble Truths. That such interpretations of the sutras are the worst of all is beyond question, an absurdity not worthy of discussion."
If you have spoken to the top leaders of SGI, you will know that they are not much different than the Zen monks, confusing the very basic concepts of Buddhism with meaningless but sometimes ornate rhetoric. They are also like Sammibo, a former disciple of Nichiren Daishonin who became arrogant thus distorting his teachings. If you haven't spoken to the top leaders, here are some examples.
"In the November 9, 1992 World Tribune (WT) p. 5, the late Richard Causton, former general director of the SGI-UK, stated,
"We must deeply understand that the heritage of the Universal Law of Nam-myoho-renge-kyo can only be transmitted through organizations joined in unity, based on faith in Nichiren Daishonin's Buddhism and the principle of the oneness of master and disciple." (emphasis added). Mr. Causton also explains his reference to "the oneness of master and disciple" as follows: "All of us who chant Nam-myoho-renge-kyo, which our ultimate master, Nichiren Daishonin, taught us, can develop the eyes of the Buddha; but it is President Ikeda, our master in life, who guides us through the rocks and shoals of this life, with pride and gratitude. President Ikeda has taught me everything. "The article also states: "Hence, the master gives his guidance based on his interpretations of the Gosho in contemporary terms and his experience of action, both for his own human revolution and for guiding the movement for kosen-rufu. We as disciples, must then set out to prove its validity for ourselves . .
Please note the focus on President Ikeda and not on the Eternal Shakyamuni, Namu myoho Renge kyo, the Lotus Sutra, nor the Daishonin.
"An editorial in the WT of November 16, 1992, p. 2, stated:
"One way [of making 'sincerity' real in our lives] is to constantly renew our determination to live with sincerity by putting President Ikeda's guidance into action every day . . . It's important to study Nichiren Daishonin's writings and the guidance of President Ikeda, but unless we put all these words into action, they are meaningless."
In the September 12, 1994 WT, p. 5, Senior Vice General Director David Kasahara stated:
” . . . The more we strictly follow the Law, including, in my mind, President Ikeda’s guidance, the more capable we become at being flexible in our awareness of what others need for their happiness. . . .”
The Law is President Ikeda’s guidance according to SGI. SGI members chant Nam(u) Myoho renge kyo with their mouths but Nam(u) Daisaku Ikeda and Nam(u) Daisaku Ikeda’s guidance with their hearts. Next, he will have his guidance inscribed on the Gohonzon.
It is also implied that President Ikeda's guidance is superior to the guidance of the Gohonzon, Buddha Shakyamuni, and Nichiren Daishonin.
"In the January 11, 1993 WT, p. 4, Mr. Ikeda stated:
"Since the Buddhist way of mentor and disciple is the ultimate way for humanity, it is impossible to grasp even the tiniest fragment of it if your efforts are only half-hearted. How faithfully did Mr. Toda follow and protect Mr. Makiguchi? And how faithfully did I follow and protect Mr. Toda? To a degree nearly unimaginable by people today. I could not hope to serve that great leader of Buddhism, Mr. Toda, without a determination to give up my own life if necessary. In that fierce determination we find the very essence of what it is to be human."
The Daishonin's master was the Eternal Shakyamuni and the Lotus Sutra. Again, again and again he stated to rely on the Law and not on the person.
In the May 3, 1996 WT, p. 10, Mr. Ikeda stated:
"Ultimately, Buddhism comes down to the person. I did not wait to place my trust in President Toda until I had learned about the Daishonin's teachings. Rather, I came to trust Buddhism because I first believed in the person, Josei Toda."
Rely on the person and not on the Law is the teaching of the Soka Gakkai while Nichiren teaches in On Repaying Debts of Gratitude:
"In a scripture called the Nirvana Sutra, the Buddha says, “Rely on the Law and not upon persons.” Relying on the Law here means relying on the various sutras. Not relying upon persons means not relying on persons other than the Buddha, such as the bodhisattvas Universal Worthy and Manjushrī or the various Buddhist teachers I have enumerated earlier."
In the SGI May study preparation lecture on Letter to Misawa by the head of the SGI study department, the jist of Greg Martin's lecture was that, through faith in the oneness of mentor and disciple, faith that the disciple is one with the Buddha, Daisaku Ikeda (specifically and our seniors in faith, generally), we can prevent the Devil of the Sixth Heaven from entering into our lives and organization. Don't drop "oneness" when entrusting yourself to President Ikeda or a senior or even when discussing the mentor disciple relationship. Obviously this was a very very important point because he made it several times).
Another "important" point he made, was not to succumb to the tantalizing temptation for power and authority [except in relation to the mentor, Daisaku Ikeda and your seniors in faith]. This was another example of double speak.
Select a mentor (someone like Ikeda and your seniors) who has defeated the Devil of the Sixth Heaven . Substitute wisdom for faith (faith in the mentor and your seniors). About the organization he said, one reed can't stand alone which is double talk because one moment earlier he discussed self reliant faith and practice and in the next moment, reliance on SGI.
Greg Martin went on in his lecture on the Letter to Misawa to say that we can transform ourselves through reading and putting president Ikeda's guidance into practice but he never touched upon those enemies of the Lotus Sutra, such as the Shingon priests and their teachings nor did he discuss the principle of not begrudging one's life for the Lotus Sutra. Neither did he mention Nichiren having contrasted strong faith with the weak faith of the Nun Usabusa. He also talked very little about the Supreme Votary of the Lotus Sutra, Nichiren Daishonin. However, he did mention the Daimoku and teaching others to the best of their ability but his conclusion was that the one vehicle to realize the widespread propagation of the Law (Kosen Rufu) is the teaching of mentor and disciple. The reality is, this important writing of Nichiren Daishonin has nothing to say about anything that remotely resembles the SGI teachings on mentor and disciple.
In general the SGI maintains, like the zen school,
"The Lotus Sutra is a finger pointing to the moon while the Zen School is the moon itself. After grasping the moon there is no need for the finger to point at it. Zen is the heart of the Buddha while the Lotus Sutra is merely His words. Having finished preaching all the sutras, including the Lotus, the Buddha picked up a bunch of flowers and gave it to Kasyapa because he alone understood what the Buddha meant. As proof the Buddha entrusted him with His kesa (vestment), which had been handed down through twenty-eight patriarchs of Buddhism in India to six patriarchs of Buddhism in China."
They assert either that the Lotus Sutra has lost its power or it is too difficult to understand without the instruction of their mentor Daisaku Ikeda.
Depreciating the Daishonin, the Lotus Sutra, and especially the Gohonzon, (the representation of the Law and Eternal Buddha), Daisaku Ikeda and the top SGI leaders prove themselves, the Third of the Three Powerful Enemies of this present age. In fact, Daisaku Ikeda, attempting to usurp the rightful position of Shakyamuni Buddha of the Juryo Chapter of the Lotus Sutra and Nichiren Daishonin, is worse than Devedatta.
Hope he OK. Such mess
ReplyDeletefrom very mixed up roots comes very mixed up fruit. stop with the stupidity.
ReplyDeletegregorio
I see why you did not write about Devadatta, Mark. How else could you make your scandalous statement/premise and end on your "unproven conclusion"--- that Ikeda is "worse" than Devadatta? Just another example of you promoting our personal animus -- your personal opinion, which of course, in America, you are entitled to do. However, you aren't entitled to your own facts.
ReplyDeleteDevadatta, a relative of the Buddh, was openly verbally attacking Shakyamuni--- was in fact, involved in actions to harm or kill the Buddha. As the story goes, Devadatta's hateful actions were due to jealousy of his "cousin" over the affections of a woman.
Closest I have seen to behavior that rivals Devadatta, are your infamous battles on Fraught with Peril-- a forum shut down due to the level of abusive language and threats of violence amongst your minions and your critics!
Being so careless with your entitlement here as a moderator; posting total nonsense with no regard for facts, history, etc., is your legacy.
But here, you have another opportunity to dial down your zealotry rhetoric and admit error....
Ikeda has as little in common with Devadatta as you do with Nichiren! Nichiren was well read/studied and measured in his accurate use of analogy.
~Katie Higgins
I always chant for Dr Mark rogow. He's the man my wise and erudite religion inspiration
ReplyDeletePlease correct this poor soul , unless you need this drivel of praise to validate you.
DeleteReally. Its Ikeda and SGI which needs correcting.
Deleteyour ego must be fed-neh?
DeleteMark, I'm thinking that your thinking - enuff!....why stick your head in the lion's mouth any longer - subjecting yourself to such abusive flagellation. No, we can't let them win by shutting down the shop.....but, give this rudimentary idea some thought: Friday nights are special in my neighborhood....because, I have HBO, a big screen TV, and, Bill Maher.....and, neighbors that want to come together to commiserate and laugh together in an effort to gain, more deeply, the perspectives from Bill's specialized, highly intelligent guests. It lends consolation and is conducive to, perhaps, a better and enjoyable weekend. So, basically: during the week, the readership will submit their pressing questions that they would want YOU to answer. At some point Mark, a person, hopefully a lot of persons will emerge with the wisdom derived from their correct practice and faith........of course, your own words can be supported by and ended with scripture...additionally, others can contribute by adding to or submitting their own answers........this idea will need much more refinement and thought....but the hope is that 1) Friday's will become the day/night to check your Blog 2) that practitioners will have a means to have their nagging questions addressed 3) an end to the slander - it just won't be tolerated and published and besides, the format is not conducive to it anyway 3) the Blog will perpetuate itself naturally without such Herculean efforts on your part......daisy, daisy, give me your answer do, I'm half crazeeeee.....I am a Robot...beddy-by time......more tomorrow......
ReplyDeletewith their own answers
Or, perhaps, Mark could allow for discussion amongst the participants on his blog, as opposed to publishing responses to him and controlling the narrative here ?
DeleteTell me, Maxwell, how Mark differs from SGI in this regard ?
Or go deeper and contemplate his intention!
~ Katie Higgins
Sounds like you are asking Makn to allow actual discussion of the teachings here.
DeleteA quick read through even the past two months of this blog suggests his goal is to confuse his readers and obfuscate his role as moderator with his desire to control the narrative.
Take a look at ARBN and you’ll see the exact tactics used by chas— dominating an unmoderated forum !
Kudos , to Maxwell for a very gentle approach to toning down Mark’s ego! Will Mark’s allow actual discussion amongst readers here? My guess is he is fearful of losing control and petrified of being exposed as a phony.
However foolish Mark is in assuming he is not already exposed, this forum has become his undoing—
even if sincere believers are relegated to troll status here, there is substantial evidence that Mark’s zealotry has caused him to lose his true mind. ~ Katie
These messages were not intended to be published
ReplyDeletebut it is you, mark, constantly attacking, defaming , mocking and condemning “ leaders of believers chanting the daimoku “.
ReplyDeleteit is you, mark, whose abusive attacks fill your blog “
looks like projection !
Mark, i sent you a message from my g-mail ...rmaxw69@gmail.com......it may wind up in your trash!....can you check that out?.....more later, RW
ReplyDeleteWill message you from my gmail, maxwell
DeleteMaxwell is a nasty gun loving racist . He has been posting racist garbage here for years. Screw that guy he is no Buddhist he is a fascist
ReplyDeleteWhere did. People like maxwell and musk go wrong? They support the racist serial killer Rittenhouse. The answer Is that they were always white supremacists
ReplyDeleteSgi greedy unspiritual radioactive buffoons
ReplyDeleteSgi caused fukushima
ReplyDeleteSgi are breakers of families
ReplyDeleteee gad. stumbled into a trump rally. what mark and trump share is a knack for bringing out the lower herd instincts in malcontents and under achievers. probably not coincidence.
Delete